Application fees can eat into what you save when you refinance, so it pays to add them up before you switch. If you live in the Barossa Valley and your loan is feeling a bit pricey, this chat is for you.
A lower rate looks great on paper. But a new loan can come with costs, and those costs need to be smaller than what you save.
What Fees Can You Pay When You Refinance a Home Loan?
When you refinance a home loan, you may pay an application fee on the new loan, a discharge fee to close the old one, and a break fee if you leave a fixed rate early. Amounts vary by lender, so you need to ask each one.
ASIC's Moneysmart lists the usual suspects. They are a break fee on a fixed-rate loan, a discharge or termination fee when you close your current loan, and an application fee on the new loan. If you stay with your current lender but move to a different loan, there may be a switching fee instead. Moneysmart also says you may be liable for stamp duty and should check with the lender. If you have less than 20 per cent equity, lenders mortgage insurance (LMI) might apply as well, and that can push up the cost of switching.
A discharge fee can include legal fees and land registry costs. A break fee only applies to fixed-rate loans, not variable ones.
Ask for the fee schedule from your current lender and the new one before you commit. Our refinancing page explains how we look at this with you.
Are There Exit Fees When You Leave Your Lender?
In most cases, lenders cannot charge a fee for ending a home loan if it was signed on or after 1 July 2011 and is secured by residential property. That rule has exceptions, because it does not cover break fees or discharge fees.
So a plain exit fee is largely off the table for newer loans. A discharge fee or a fixed rate break fee can still show up. If you have paid a fee that was prohibited, the law says you can recover it. If you think that applies to you, ask your lender or chat with us first.
Fixed Rate Break Costs: When Your Fixed Rate Period Is Ending
If your fixed rate period is ending, you can usually avoid a break fee by waiting until the term finishes. A break fee is charged only when you end a fixed loan early.
The trade-off is timing. If you wait, you stay on your current rate a bit longer. If you leave early, you may pay the fee but start saving sooner. The sums are worth doing with your actual numbers. Your lender should be able to give you a break cost figure for your loan, and the figure depends on your contract and the date you leave.
A lender cannot raise an early termination fee on a fixed loan, or change how it is worked out so that it costs you more, after you have signed.
How to Work Out If Refinancing Is Worth It: An Example
Refinancing is worth it when your total savings over the time you plan to keep the loan are bigger than the total costs of switching. Here is a worked illustration using 6.75% p.a., which is an example rate only and not an offer.
Consider a Barossa couple with a $500,000 loan balance and 25 years left. At 6.75% p.a., the repayment is about $3,455 a month. They find a lender that could offer a rate 0.50 percentage points lower, so 6.25% p.a. At that rate, the repayment is about $3,298 a month, which is around $157 less each month.
Now they add up the costs. Say the discharge fee and the new application fee come to $800 in total, and there is no break fee because their loan is variable. At $157 a month, they cover that cost in roughly five months. After that, the lower repayment is money back in their pocket each month. Their loan term is unchanged, so they are not stretching out the debt to get that result.
If the fees had been $4,000 because of a break fee, it would take about 25 months. That might still be worth it, but only if they plan to hold the loan that long and the lower rate is actually offered. These figures are illustrative only. Your own rate, loan size and fees will be different, so try a calculator and then talk to us.
Does the Cheaper Rate Always Win?
Not always. A lower rate can be cancelled out by higher fees or by losing features you value, like an offset account or redraw.
ASIC's guidance for lenders says a switch should produce overall cost savings that outweigh any loss of benefits, or at least suit your needs more closely. Those costs include broker fees. Brokers also have a legal duty to act in your interests, and that can include telling you to stay put if switching would cost more than it saves.
If you pay a lower rate but extend your loan term, your repayments can drop only because you are paying for longer. That means more interest overall, so it helps to see both numbers side by side.
Refinancing an Investment Property: Fees and Tax
Some refinancing costs on an investment loan can be tax deductible, but how much depends on how the borrowed money is used. You should talk to your accountant before you rely on any of it.
The ATO treats borrowing expenses, such as loan establishment fees, mortgage broker fees and valuation fees required for loan approval, as deductible over five years, or the loan term if shorter. Total borrowing expenses of $100 or less can be claimed in the year they are incurred. Any part of the loan used for private purposes is not deductible. If you add extra money to the loan for personal spending, interest on that part has to be split from the rental part.
The tax rules around negative gearing have also changed, and they turn on when you bought the property and whether it is a new build. Check with your accountant or the ATO before refinancing an investment property, as the effect of a refinance on negative gearing treatment is not clearly set out in current guidance.
Refinancing Government Scheme Loans
If you bought with the Australian Government 5% Deposit Scheme, you may be able to refinance and keep the scheme's benefit, but only with another Participating Lender. You also cannot increase the loan or extend the term.
Moving to a lender outside the scheme counts as fully repaying the loan, so the scheme benefit is lost. If your balance is still above 80 per cent of the property value, the new lender may charge LMI or other costs. If you are in this boat, we can check your options on our first home buyers page or talk it through at an appointment.
Before you go, a brief word on how we work. Susi and the team at SR Finance can compare your current loan with other options. You can read more about us or look at our home loan options if you want to browse first. Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you, and we will run the numbers on your fees together.